re: today's xkcd
Oct. 8th, 2010 05:05 pmSince I've gotten asked.
It's about airfoils and misconceptions.
Pretty funny joke, considering that even at a university level some people still get confused about airfoils. The short answer is that fluid dynamics is COMPLICATED. In 3D space, there are a lot of factors in dealing with them.
Why do they get confused? Because the math is right, and math is sometimes hard to translate into language. Particularly the English language, I've learned. (yes, there are languages that make math easier to understand... they are countries that tend to kick the US's butt in math scores. but that's another topic). If the math were wrong, we'd have no planes flying!
But the longer answer in how airfoils create lift is not just based on flow movement; it's based on circulation. The problem with the standard (wrong) explanation is that they just don't describe Bernoulli's Principle right. Bernoulli's principle is really about momentum and circulation. And the base equation is a simplification of much more complicated fluid dynamics, but I won't go into that.
( the longer explanation )
It's about airfoils and misconceptions.
Pretty funny joke, considering that even at a university level some people still get confused about airfoils. The short answer is that fluid dynamics is COMPLICATED. In 3D space, there are a lot of factors in dealing with them.
Why do they get confused? Because the math is right, and math is sometimes hard to translate into language. Particularly the English language, I've learned. (yes, there are languages that make math easier to understand... they are countries that tend to kick the US's butt in math scores. but that's another topic). If the math were wrong, we'd have no planes flying!
But the longer answer in how airfoils create lift is not just based on flow movement; it's based on circulation. The problem with the standard (wrong) explanation is that they just don't describe Bernoulli's Principle right. Bernoulli's principle is really about momentum and circulation. And the base equation is a simplification of much more complicated fluid dynamics, but I won't go into that.
( the longer explanation )